Frequently Asked Questions
Can the McAllister MC4536 be fitted with progressive lenses?
What face shapes work best with rectangle eyeglasses?
Are these frames suitable for high prescription lenses?
How should I clean my McAllister eyeglasses?
What is the size of the McAllister MC4536?
Is McAllister a reputable eyewear brand?
Compare With Similar Frames
How the McAllister MC4536 Eyeglasses stacks up against the closest alternatives we carry.
- Same brand quality and heritage
- Similar price range ($65-$70)
- Rectangle shape with full-rim construction
- Recognized designer brand with iconic crocodile logo
- Similar price range to MC4536
- Rectangle full-rim design
- Competitive pricing in the same range
- Rectangle full-rim construction
- Good option for budget-conscious shoppers
Read the full comparison
McAllister MC4536 vs. Similar Rectangle Frames
If you're considering the McAllister MC4536, you might also be weighing a few other rectangle frames in the same price range. Here's how the MC4536 stacks up against comparable options in our collection.
MC4536 vs. McAllister MC4519
Both frames come from the same McAllister heritage line, so you're getting the same quality standards and American eyewear legacy. The MC4519 is priced similarly at $65-$70 and shares the full-rim rectangle construction that makes McAllister frames so versatile for prescription lenses. The main difference comes down to specific style details and color options—if you like the McAllister aesthetic but want to compare exact frame shapes and available colors, both are solid choices. Either way, you're getting a prescription-ready frame that handles progressives and bifocals with ease.
MC4536 vs. Lacoste L3804B
The Lacoste L3804B ($62-$66) offers a designer alternative at nearly the same price point. Lacoste brings its sportswear heritage to eyewear, so you get the recognizable crocodile logo and a slightly more athletic aesthetic. If brand recognition matters to you and you prefer a sportier look, the Lacoste might edge ahead. However, the MC4536 offers a more classic, understated style without prominent branding—better if you want frames that blend into professional settings. Both are full-rim rectangle frames that work well with prescriptions.
MC4536 vs. Aristar AR18432
The Aristar AR18432 ($55-$67) competes directly on price and offers similar full-rim rectangle construction. Aristar is a solid budget-friendly brand, but it doesn't carry the same heritage story as McAllister's 225-year American optical legacy. If you're purely price-shopping and want the most affordable option, Aristar is worth considering. But if you value brand history and the confidence that comes with a well-established name, the MC4536's connection to the founder of American optometry gives it an edge—especially at such a small price difference.
Why Choose the MC4536?
The McAllister MC4536 hits a sweet spot: heritage brand credibility, versatile rectangle styling, full prescription compatibility including progressives, and an accessible price point under $70. The three color options (Blush Tortoise, Purple Brown, Olive) give you choices beyond basic black or brown, and the unisex design means these frames work for anyone. If you want dependable, everyday eyeglasses with a bit of American optical history behind them, the MC4536 delivers without overthinking it.
At a Glance
McAllister MC4519 Eyeglasses
Pros:
- Same brand quality and heritage
- Similar price range ($65-$70)
- Rectangle shape with full-rim construction
- Multiple color options available
Cons:
- May have different sizing that affects fit
- Color options differ from MC4536
- Specific style details vary from MC4536
Lacoste L3804B Eyeglasses
Pros:
- Recognized designer brand with iconic crocodile logo
- Similar price range to MC4536
- Rectangle full-rim design
- Established brand reputation in sportswear and eyewear
Cons:
- May have different fit and sizing
- Brand premium may affect perceived value
- Style may be more sporty than classic
Aristar AR18432 Eyeglasses
Pros:
- Competitive pricing in the same range
- Rectangle full-rim construction
- Good option for budget-conscious shoppers
- Prescription-ready like the MC4536
Cons:
- Less established brand heritage than McAllister
- May have different quality standards
- Fewer color options or style variations



