Product Details
Color Details
Size DetailsFrequently Asked Questions
Are Oakley Belleville 9491 sunglasses prescription-ready?
What size fit is the Oakley Belleville?
What is Oakley Prizm lens technology?
What is O Matter frame material?
What is the Oakley Players Collection?
Do Oakley Belleville sunglasses have UV protection?
Compare With Similar Frames
How the Oakley Belleville 9491 Sunglasses stacks up against the closest alternatives we carry.
- Lower starting price ($141.38 vs $192)
- Iconic, proven design with decades of heritage
- 59mm lens width may fit medium-to-large faces better
- Lower starting price ($121.10 vs $192)
- Shield lens design offers maximum coverage
- Extremely popular model with wide availability
Read the full comparison
Oakley Belleville vs. Holbrook XL vs. Sutro: Which Frame Fits Your Style?
Choosing between Oakley's lifestyle frames comes down to fit, coverage, and aesthetic preference. The Belleville 9491 represents Oakley's newest design direction—a high-wrap rectangular frame from the 2024 Players Collection that blends 1960s inspiration with modern performance. The Holbrook XL 9417 is a proven classic with square lines inspired by Hollywood's golden age, while the Sutro 9406 offers a contemporary shield design for maximum coverage.
Frame Design & Coverage
The Belleville's high-wrap dual-lens design provides excellent peripheral coverage with a 61mm lens width, making it ideal for wider faces and high nose bridges. The Holbrook XL features a 59mm square lens with a keyhole bridge—slightly smaller but still considered a large fit. The Sutro takes a different approach with its single-shield lens that wraps around for maximum field of view, though it may feel less traditional than the Belleville's dual-lens setup.
Style & Heritage
If you want exclusive, statement-making style, the Belleville stands out with its Fractal logo, full Oakley wordmark on the temples, and Players Collection pedigree. The Holbrook XL offers iconic, versatile style that's been refined over years—it's the safe choice that works everywhere. The Sutro delivers bold, athletic-inspired style that's become synonymous with cycling and running culture but translates well to streetwear.
Price & Value
The Belleville starts at $192, positioning it as a premium option within Oakley's lifestyle range. The Holbrook XL ($141.38 starting) and Sutro ($121.10 starting) offer more accessible entry points with proven track records. All three frames feature O Matter construction, Prizm lens technology, and 100% UV protection—the price difference reflects exclusivity and design complexity rather than core performance.
Our Recommendation
Choose the Belleville if you want the newest Oakley design with extra-large fit, high-wrap coverage, and Players Collection exclusivity. Opt for the Holbrook XL if you prefer classic square styling with proven versatility at a lower price. Pick the Sutro if you want maximum lens coverage in a shield design that's become a modern Oakley icon. All three are prescription-ready and built to Oakley's exacting standards.
At a Glance
Oakley Holbrook XL 9417 Sunglasses
Pros:
- Lower starting price ($141.38 vs $192)
- Iconic, proven design with decades of heritage
- 59mm lens width may fit medium-to-large faces better
- More colorway and lens options available
- Keyhole nose bridge for classic fit
Cons:
- Less wrap coverage than Belleville's high-wrap design
- Traditional square shape less distinctive than Belleville's modern aesthetic
- Standard Oakley ellipse logo instead of full wordmark
- Not part of the Players Collection
Oakley Sutro 9406 Sunglasses
Pros:
- Lower starting price ($121.10 vs $192)
- Shield lens design offers maximum coverage
- Extremely popular model with wide availability
- Lighter weight for extended wear
- More lens and frame color options
Cons:
- Single-lens shield design less versatile for some face shapes
- Less retro-inspired aesthetic than Belleville
- Not part of the exclusive Players Collection
- May feel less substantial than Belleville's dual-lens frame